Jump to content

Ctrl+V


Ragitsu

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 15.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Ragitsu

    9682

  • Certified

    2512

  • tkdguy

    1156

  • Clonus

    825

I've played DnD tabletop since 1993. I think most of your points about what is a good RPG story are good, but the way I see it the problem is much deeper. Started when WOTC bought TSR. They focus less on novel based content and more to overpower high fantasy stories. Faerun has became a world where you can't walk 5 miles without some espetacular world changing event happens and the way I see it this is just bad writing. If in the past the references for DMing and creating an world/adventure campaign were classics like Lord of the ring, Dracula, The Sword of Shannara, The Arabian Nights and many others, nowdays is a mix between Micheal Bay, Marvel or any other overpowered nonsense story with a medieval high fantasy theme. But A LOT of people like and buy it. The good old RPG still lives in the books from TSR, and for a tabletop point of view, there is so much content that you don't need anything new to have som old good fun with it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Think of it this way: Caldwell was a Colonel and he was a career military man. He was an old Colonel. He had yet to make it to Brigadier General. Even after all his great Commanding of the Daedalus through multiple events and battles he has still yet to be recognized as deserving of a promotion to General. Politically speaking, the Daedalus was old NEWS.

 

Meanwhile, Atlantis was constantly pumping out new discovered advanced alien technology. Politically. that would be a great place for recognition and his promotion. Then we consider that he did not like the manner in which Atlantis, humanity's greatest hope of advancement, was being run and put at what he saw as unnecessary risk. He could take over at Atlantis and have it running smoothly to the point where is was a cushy job full of recognition and promotions where he could ride out his remaining years until retirement.

 

This is important, because a Colonel (at the time) only made $4000 a month when retired, but: Brigadier General = $4800 a month. Major General = $5,500 a month. Lieutenant General = $5,870 a month. General = $6,650 a month. These retirement estimates are important because in reality a Colonel could not take Active Command of an entire base, only temporary Command. Because a stronger contingent was being sent to Atlantis it would soon become a permanent base instead of an outpost. By becoming the military Commander at Atlantis Caldwell would already be guaranteed the promotion to Brigadier General and easily make Major General in a year.

 

If things went well, he would pass Lieutenant General and make General before another 2 years. And we now circle back to what he saw as mismanagement of the Atlantis base. Caldwell was a career military man but he saw and described himself as "always being a career military strategist". This means that his greatest drive was to build Command infrastructure and plan for contingencies and outthink the enemy. Atlantis Command position would allow him to do this while also allowing him to utilize the greatest technology and tools the galaxy had ever seen. In short, there was a myriad of reasons why he would want to take Command of Atlantis instead of risking his life on the Daedalus for no recognition and his hands tied and probably dying in a tin can in space.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archer season 1 is the guy who investigated a derelict space vessel and discovered the crew were hooked to machines to suck out their cerebro-spinal fluid for the convenience of space vampires, decided to run away from the weird scariness, then decided to change his mind hours later and came back to a confrontation with the space vampires that he would have avoided if he hadn't vacillated.

He's the guy who on discovering a military secret of his allies because he wouldn't just go away when asked to and decided to expose this classified information, triggering an interstellar incident that nearly erupted into a massive war.

He's the guy who took his dog down to p== on a tree that was the centerpiece of a community he was trying to open diplomatic relations with.

He's the guy who first asked his science officer how her people would investigate a new planet, and on learning that they would be cautious and methodical decided instead to treat it like a campout in his parent's backyard.

He's the guy who, on discovering that human ships were being preyed upon by space pirates decided to do nothing except keep the civilians from trying to fight back.

He's the guy who had a cure for the disease that was going to render an entire species extinct and decided they didn't deserve it because not having exterminated their neanderthals made them unfit to live.

He's the guy who on discovering a crew member had been implanted with alien offspring decided that was funny and not something scary and life-endangering.

He's the guy whose plans when encountering hostiles always started with "OK, first I let myself get captured..."

Truly Jonathan Archer was the greatest commander in Starfleet's history. His brilliance dazzled all who beheld it

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Usually, in fiction (and real life, to an extent), a lengthy name/title is indicative of influence if not outright station. However...what if the opposite were true? What if you - a commoner - are born into a long name and can only shorten this designation by ascending the social strata?

 

Bobalethoga Macrathiss the Second of the Granite Plains -> Bob (the king).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Darkness is all about concealment and confusion: ignorance is very much the name of the game. Inversely, the light is pure unvarnished awareness: you know where you are and you know everything else knows where you are as well. Because one's sense of vision is at the height of its acuity in broad daylight, horrors that manage to surprise us when the sun is unobstructed are extra effective than those lurking in a patch of shadow. As you said, the setup has to be executed just right for it to work properly...but the payoff? It is nothing short of fantastic.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Quality Gear
This week we kick off a new series exploring Gear, Power Level, and design concepts.
 
 
#Metahumans #Superheroes #TTRPG #TTRPGSolidarity #TTRPGRising #Gear
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...